Jeff Lion All articles
Film & Opinion

The Calm Before the Casserole: Why Thanksgiving Eve Belongs to the Multiplex

Jeff Lion
The Calm Before the Casserole: Why Thanksgiving Eve Belongs to the Multiplex

Photo: Eden, Janine and Jim from New York City, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

There is a specific kind of quiet that shows up in a grocery store on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving. It is not peaceful quiet. It is the quiet of forty people all quietly panicking about the same can of pumpkin puree. I know it well. It's the sound of the holiday starting whether you're ready or not.

This year, Thanksgiving Eve falls on Wednesday, November 25, and I've already made my decision: I'm doing the dough at four, and I'm in a theater seat by 7:10. Not because I don't care about the holiday. Because I care about it enough to want two hours of nothing before it starts.

It Started as an Accident

I did not grow up with a Thanksgiving Eve movie tradition. I grew up with a Thanksgiving Eve of errands, and then a Thanksgiving Eve of driving, and then a Thanksgiving Eve of sitting in a driveway with a car full of groceries waiting for someone to come help carry them in.

The first time I ended up at the movies on that Wednesday, it was pure avoidance. I had volunteered to pick up the rolls, which took nine minutes, and I had roughly two hours before anyone expected me back. So I pulled into the multiplex the way you pull into a rest stop — not because it's the destination, but because you need to sit down.

What I found in there stuck with me. The lobby was calm. The concession line was four people deep. The biggest auditorium was maybe a third full. Nobody was there for an event. Everybody was there for a pause.

The Usher Who Knows the Whole Schedule

Two years ago I got to talking with an usher near the rope line, a guy in his twenties with a lanyard full of keys and the specific cheerfulness of someone who has already done the hard part of his shift. I asked him what the busiest night of the year was. He didn't say this night. He said the night the big franchise stuff opens, and the day after Christmas, and basically any Saturday in July.

Thanksgiving Eve, he told me, is strange. Half the auditoriums are dark. The people who do show up are unusually polite. They say excuse me. They don't leave their trash. They laugh at things that aren't that funny, like they're relieved to be laughing at all.

He also told me something I've thought about every year since: the 7:40 show is the quiet one. The 7:10 is the family one. If you want to hear yourself think, take the later slot. It's free advice and I've never once ignored it.

The Solo Row

Here is what I kept noticing. A woman two rows ahead of me with a canvas tote that clearly came from a bookstore, no popcorn, no phone out. A guy on the aisle who bought the smallest size of popcorn and put his jacket on the seat next to him, which is a particular move — the jacket dates the seat, so nobody slides in and starts talking.

None of them looked lonely. That's the part I couldn't stop turning over. They looked like people who had successfully carved out a couple of hours that belonged to them and nobody else, in a week designed to have zero such hours.

I think about the logistics of that a lot now. Somebody in that row probably had a turkey defrosting in a fridge. Somebody probably had in-laws arriving at noon the next day. And here they were, taking a number at a popcorn counter like it was a spa.

The Family of Four in Row F

Behind me sat two parents and two kids, maybe eight and eleven. They weren't there for the big spectacle — they were at the same unremarkable movie I was, which is the whole point. The dad did the thing where he holds four tickets in one hand and four drink orders in his head. The mom had a phone flashlight on, checking something, and then she turned it off and put it in her bag and didn't look at it again until the lights came up.

At one point the younger kid asked a loud question. Nobody shushed him. Nobody had to. The theater was empty enough that his voice just hung there and dissolved, and his mother answered him quietly, and the movie kept going.

That's the thing about a half-full room. It makes room for people to be people. There's no pressure to perform being a good audience. You can whisper. You can get up. You can cry a little at a trailer and nobody notices because there's nobody sitting close enough to notice.

Why the Night Works

The obvious answer is that nobody is at the movies on Thanksgiving Eve, so you get the place to yourself. That's true but it's not the reason I keep going back.

The reason is that Thanksgiving Eve is the last night before the house fills up. Before the extra chairs, the extra cars in the driveway, the extra volume on the TV during the parade. It's the night when the holiday is still entirely ahead of you and hasn't yet become a series of tasks you're behind on.

A two-hour movie is the only thing on the calendar that Wednesday that doesn't want anything from you. You don't have to bring a dish. You don't have to be charming. You just have to sit down in the dark and let something happen.

My Rules for the 25th

I'm keeping it simple this year. Pie dough done by four, in the fridge, no negotiation. Ticket bought online the night before so there's no counter conversation. Phone on silent and in the jacket pocket, not on the armrest. No checking the running time, no checking whether the roads are bad, no checking anything. And I'm taking the 7:40.

I'll be home by ten with the crust already resting and the house still quiet. Then the parade can come, and the casserole can come, and the dining room can turn into an airport terminal, and I'll have had my two hours.

If you're in a theater on Wednesday night and the place feels weirdly calm, that's not a fluke. That's the whole thing. It's the quietest room in America that week, and for once, that's exactly what it's for.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Waiter Had a Whole Life: Thirty Days of Watching Everything but the Leads

The Waiter Had a Whole Life: Thirty Days of Watching Everything but the Leads

What the One-Sheet Promised: Four Weeks of Poster-Only Movie Nights

What the One-Sheet Promised: Four Weeks of Poster-Only Movie Nights

The Part After the Plot: What Thirty Full Credit Rolls Taught Me

The Part After the Plot: What Thirty Full Credit Rolls Taught Me